10 Pet-Related Arguments Every Couple Has Had

Pets bring love, laughter, and sometimes a little bit of chaos into a relationship. While they can strengthen a couple’s bond, they also come with plenty of disagreements. From who takes care of the pet to what they’re allowed to do, couples often find themselves in heated debates over their furry (or feathery, or scaly) companions.

Whether you’re new to pet parenthood or a seasoned pro, chances are you’ve had at least a few of these pet-related arguments with your significant other.

1. “Who’s Taking the Dog Out?”

Side view of anonymous ethnic female wearing shorts strolling with dog on leash on pavement near metal fence on street
Photo by Samson Katt

It’s cold, raining, or just too early. No one wants to leave the comfort of bed, and the standoff begins. Someone has to take the dog out, but both of you suddenly have urgent reasons why it shouldn’t be you.

2. “The Pet Sleeps Where?”

Cute kitten sleeping peacefully indoors on a colorful bedspread, perfect for pet lovers.
Photo by Fabricio Trujillo

One of you thinks the pet should sleep in bed, while the other insists they belong on the floor (or in another room entirely). Meanwhile, the pet has already made themselves comfortable under the covers.


Want more pet content and exclusive offers? Sign up for our newsletter today!


3. “You’re Spoiling Them Too Much!”

A person holding a bowl of blueberries and yogurt
Photo by Tanya Nikan

One person sticks to strict feeding guidelines, while the other sneaks extra treats under the table. Arguments about overfeeding, table scraps, and weight gain are a regular occurrence in pet-friendly households.

4. “Stop Using That Baby Voice!”

A woman lovingly cuddles her Shih Tzu puppy, wrapped in a warm blanket outdoors.
Photo by Helena Lopes

Some people love using an exaggerated baby voice when talking to their pets. Others find it unbearable. This argument comes up when one person is just trying to communicate, while the other is cringing.

5. “Who’s Cleaning That Up?”

A grayscale photo of a person mopping the floor in a modern living room.
Photo by Tima Miroshnichenko

Whether it’s an accident on the rug, a chewed-up shoe, or a knocked-over plant, there’s always a debate about whose turn it is to clean up after the pet’s latest mess.

6. “They’re Just Excited!” vs. “They Need to Calm Down!”

An adult man training a fluffy West Siberian Laika dog outdoors in a sunny park setting.
Photo by Zen Chung

One person thinks the pet’s zoomies are adorable. The other thinks they’re out of control. Whether it’s barking, jumping, or running around the house, there’s always a disagreement on what’s “cute” and what’s “too much.”

7. “We Need to Set Some Boundaries!”

animal, cat, feline, mammal, pet, species, fauna, fur, whiskers, cat, nature, cat, cat, cat, cat
Photo by karishea

Someone thinks the pet should stay off the furniture, out of the bedroom, or away from certain areas. The other believes in a free-roam policy. This never-ending battle often ends with the pet doing whatever they want anyway.

8. “We Are NOT Getting Another One!”

Smiling woman with red hair takes a selfie with her Shiba Inu, lying on a cozy bed indoors.
Photo by Vitaly Gariev

One of you is completely content with the current pet situation. The other is already browsing adoption listings. The “just one more” debate is a frequent struggle for animal lovers.

Read More: From Furballs to Freshness: 10 Ways to Maintain a Clean Home with Pets

9. “You’re Too Strict!” vs. “You’re Too Lenient!”

Cute puppy lying on carpet, chewing a stick indoors, showcasing innocence and playfulness.
Photo by Josh Sorenson

One of you enforces the rules, while the other lets things slide. Whether it’s jumping on the couch, stealing food, or barking too much, there’s always a disagreement on how much discipline is necessary.

Read More: Which Dog Breed is Right for Your Family’s Lifestyle?

10. “They’re Not Just a Pet, They’re Family!”

A couple with their Labrador retriever enjoying a meal inside a car on a chilly day.
Photo by cottonbro studio

At the end of the day, the biggest argument is often about how much the pet means to the household. One person treats them like a beloved family member, while the other sees them as just an animal. If you’ve had this argument, you already know—there’s only one right answer.

Pets might bring their fair share of debates, but they also bring so much love. At the end of the day, a shared life with a pet (and a partner who tolerates your pet obsession) is worth every little disagreement!

Read More: Barking Back: Dispelling 10 Misguided Beliefs About Dogs

Newsletter

The Latest

Two cats relaxing in a modern living room with an automated litter box near the window.
10 Smart Home Gadgets Every Pet Owner Should Consider
A greyhound dog relaxing on a couch with its owner gently stroking it indoors.
What Happens to Your Pet If Something Happens to You? 10 Ways to Plan for Their Future
A dog walker leads a group of dogs on leashes through a sunny park trail, Pet Sitter
10 Pet Sitter Red Flags to Watch For
orange tabby cat sitting between standing man and woman inside room
15 Struggles of Dating Someone Who Doesn’t Like Pets

Providing expert tips, practical advice, and personalized product recommendations for happy and healthy pets. Part of the Castaway Studios media network.

As an Amazon Associate, PetHub USA earns from qualifying purchases.

Scroll to Top