Walk into any pet store, and you will see rows of brightly hued retractable leashes promising freedom and convenience. But are retractable leashes as dangerous as most dog trainers claim? The debate has intensified in recent years as emergency vets report unique patterns of injury linked to these ubiquitous walking aids.
While marketing their benefits, pet owners and expert dog trainers more and more recommend against them. Fresh safety studies and 2025 expert reviews bring astounding findings about retractable leash risks that all pet owners should be aware of before taking the next dog walk.
Current Safety Concerns from Veterinary Professionals
Veterinarians across the country report a consistent pattern of injuries specifically due to retractable leash safety issues. According to Dr. Sarah Mitchell, of the American Veterinary Medical Association, emergency rooms handle burns, cuts, and even severed fingers from the slim cord mechanism.
Most common retractable leash injuries seen in 2025:
- Rope burns on humans when the cord wraps around hands or legs
- Neck and tracheal injury in dogs when the dog is suddenly stopped
- Multiple dog or human entanglement injuries
- Falls and fractures when dogs bolt suddenly at full extension
The Association of Professional Dog Trainers published updated guidelines in 2025, strongly discouraging the use of retractable leashes, pointing to their impact on leash training and impulse control. Max, a German Shepherd weighing 60 pounds, was badly hurt in the neck when his retractable leash abruptly engaged while he was chasing a squirrel, creating a brutal tug and tracheal collapse, and he required emergency surgery.
Read More: Thinking of Rehoming Your Dog? Read This First
The Case for Retractable Leashes: Benefits and Proper Use
Although there are safety concerns, there are special circumstances under which dog behaviorists acknowledge the value of retractable leashes. For older or mobility-impaired owners, exercising dogs without physical effort can be invaluable.
Their advocates acknowledge that, used correctly in the proper settings, open areas, beaches, or neighborhood streets, retractable leashes offer liberty under supervision. Small dogs with weights under 25 pounds are exposed to fewer injury risks with less force brought to bear during rapid movements.
Certified trainer Lisa Rodriguez describes the secret to success: “Retractable leashes are fine for recall work in a controlled setting, but they’re not walking aids for busy streets or reactivity issues.
Read More: 15 Outdoor Games to Play With Your Dog This Spring
Expert-Recommended Alternatives for Safe Dog Walking
Veterinarians and professional trainers always recommend dog leash alternatives with better control and safety. Six-foot nylon or leather leashes remain the norm for urban walking, delivering the optimal freedom vs. control ratio.
For bigger dogs needing extra space, extended training lines (15-30 feet) provide controlled independence without the mechanical risks of retractable systems. Waist leashes, hands-free leashes, and no-pull harnesses with standard leashes address pulling problems more effectively than retractable systems.
More recent GPS collar technology in 2025 offers monitoring for dogs during off-leash play in designated fields.
Choosing the Right Option for Your Dog’s Safety
Choosing the right leash depends on your dog’s size, walking terrain, and behavior. Specialist advice in 2025 is firmly in favor of traditional leashes for everyday use, reserving retractable ones for specific training under expert guidance.
Take your dog’s impulse control, your own strength, and common walking settings into account when selecting leash gear. Begin assessing your existing leash setup today; your dog’s well-being is worth basing decisions on the latest veterinary science, not marketing-hyped convenience claims.
Ready to improve your walk? Discuss the safest leashes for your particular dog and lifestyle with your veterinarian.
Read More: 10 Rules Every Kid Should Know Before Walking the Dog Alone
