Litter Box Mistakes You Might Be Making (And Easy Fixes)

You’ve provided a clean litter box, quality litter, and a convenient location, so why is your cat suddenly using your carpet as its own personal toilet? Litter box mistakes are more common than you might think, and even small mistakes can result in bathroom issues that annoy cats and owners alike.

Most cat litter box problems come from the best of intentions that simply don’t agree with cats. Here are the most frequent mistakes and easy solutions to make the litter box a peaceful kingdom.

Wrong Box Size and Placement

Most owners choose litter boxes based on the availability of space rather than their cat’s needs. The most prevalent error is to buy a particular litter box so that it will fit into a cluttered space or a cramped area and be out of sight. Your cat must have room to turn around and dig in the box. 

Most prevalent placement and size errors:


Want more pet content and exclusive offers? Sign up for our newsletter today!


  • Too small: Boxes must be at least 1.5 times the length of your cat
  • Out of sight: Avoid basements, closets, or hidden areas
  • Too close to food: Cats prefer a space between the eating and bathroom areas

Place the litter box where your cat can easily access it, but not in the path of too much foot traffic. Whiskers, a mature Maine Coon, would not accept his basement litter box when arthritis made climbing stairs a painful chore. Moving the box to the main floor immediately solved the problem. 

Read More: 10 Adorable Things Your Cat Does When You’re Not Home

Scented Litters and Harsh Cleaners

Cats don’t tend to like strong smells, and most humans use fragrant litter to mask litter box smells. Pleasant scents that are nice to people can be overwhelming to the discerning cat nose, making them seek out other bathroom locations.

Avoid using a strongly fragrant cleanser to disinfect the box. Instead, do a weekly deep clean with warm water and mild, fragrance-free soap. 

Safe cleaning alternatives:

  • Unscented clumping litter: Most cats prefer the unscented variety
  • Warm water rinse: Daily spot cleaning using plain water
  • White vinegar solution: Natural odor remover when mixed with equal parts water (1:1 ratio) 

Read More: 10 Tips for Caring for a Pregnant Cat

Not Adhering to the “Plus One” Rule

For multi-cat households, one box for each cat, plus one, is what the owner should have. This prevents territorial battles and ensures clean boxes are always available. Single-cat households also get to have multiple boxes, especially for multi-story homes. 

Multi-box benefits:

  • Less competition: Removes territorial stress among cats
  • Backup options: Clean alternatives when one box has to be maintained
  • Odor control: Disperses waste over multiple containers 

Incorrect Litter Depth and Lack of Regular Cleaning

Most cats do not like a deep litter, and a depth of two to three inches is ideal. Too much litter is difficult to dig in, whereas too little does not give the waste sufficient cover. Daily scooping prevents odors from accumulating and driving cats away from their boxes. 

Proper maintenance schedule:

  • Daily: Scoop out all waste and clumps
  • Weekly: Completely change litter and clean the box 
  • Monthly: Vinegar solution deep cleaning if needed 

Renovating Your Litter Box Setup

Fixing litter box mistakes typically requires a number of minor adjustments, not drastic changes. Start with the most obvious issues—size, location, and hygiene—before moving on to litter-type experimentation.

If your cat suddenly starts urinating or defecating on the floor outside the litter box, discuss the situation with your veterinarian to rule out medical causes before jumping to conclusions about behavioral issues.

Ready to create a feline-friendly bathroom visit? Begin with perfect litter box placement in a peaceful, convenient location, and provide adequate boxes for your family’s needs.

Read More: Top 10 Simple Tricks to Help Calm Your Moody Cat

Newsletter

The Latest

how to tell if cat is bored
How to Tell If Your Cat Is Bored—and What to Do About It
cat 3am zoomies
Why Your Cat Is Obsessed with Zooming at 3 a.m.
tan and white basset hound
Best Breeds for Apartment Living (That Aren't Just Tiny Dogs)
dog dna tests
Why Dog DNA Tests Are More Popular Than Ever in 2025

Providing expert tips, practical advice, and personalized product recommendations for happy and healthy pets. Part of the Castaway Studios media network.

As an Amazon Associate, PetHub USA earns from qualifying purchases.

Scroll to Top